Thanks to Ashley Kahn for being rather generous in his selection of items for the Downbeat Blindfold Test done in Umbria this past December. Ashley knows what I know and played to my strengths, so it was easy for me to basically ace the test. Read the whole thing here.
(Thanks also to my old friend Enzo Capua for bringing me to Umbria so many times!)
I always turn to the Blindfold Test first when I get my new Downbeat.
Most of the interviewees have gotten safer and more political over the years, but back in the day, comparatively unfiltered comments can make for surprising and occasionally revelatory reading.
Ray Bryant in 1960 has no use for Steve Allen playing Horace Silver or Cecil Taylor, but digs George Shearing.
Gerry Mulligan in 1960 is confused by Cannonball Adderley and Bobby Timmons, which is strange enough, but then his comments on Thelonious Monk are unintentionally revealing. I am a Mulligan fan, within reason, but never dug the record Mulligan Meets Monk. Now it all makes sense. (That particular Monk recording of Irving Berlin’s “Remember” awesome, of course.)
Last year I was paging through one of the Encyclopedias of Jazz assembled by Leonard Feather and Ira Gitler. Feather cherry-picked good moments from the Blindfold Tests.



Incredibly, you can listen to many of them at this archive at the University of Idaho: https://www.lib.uidaho.edu/digital/blindfold/ Amongst so many things, it's interesting to hear Miles before he lost his voice.
As interesting as it is to read Oscar Peterson dunking on Ramsey Lewis, it's so affirming to read, for example, Stanley Turrentine on Ben Webster or Joe Williams on Blossom Dearie - the respect and love within the fraternity.